On August 12, 2022, the Civil Cassation Chamber (“SCC”) of the Supreme Tribunal of Justice (“TSJ”) published a ruling [1] declaring as meritorious (con lugar) the extraordinary appeal in cassation filed by citizen Arianne Rodríguez Almado. The ruling challenged a decision issued by the Second Superior Court for Civil, Commercial, Banking, and Traffic Matters of the Carabobo State Judicial District on November 5, 2020. This judgment ordered the proceedings to be reset to the stage of setting a deadline for the filing of the defense in a contract resolution lawsuit.
The significance of this ruling lies in establishing that the Courts of the Republic may now serve notifications via email and the social messaging application WhatsApp.
Key Highlights of the Ruling:
- Principle of Legal Presence (Estar a Derecho): Once the initial summons (citación) is served, parties are generally expected to follow the proceedings without further notice. Exceptions include notifications when a new judge takes over the case or when a trial resumes after a period of paralysis [2].
- Definition of Notification: The notification of the parties is described as “a communication act directed at them to appear in the process, learn of developments in the lawsuit, and integrate the procedural legal relationship alongside the judge and the opposing party…” [3].
- Digital Tools and Infogovernment Law: In accordance with the Infogovernment Law (Official Gazette No. 40,274), the TSJ considered that “in all events, the judge can and must order, when necessary, the notification of the parties by sending the respective notice to the provided email address and the instant messaging application and/or social network WhatsApp.”
- New Cases: Henceforth, lawsuits must include the email addresses and phone numbers of the plaintiff, their legal representative, and the defendant.
- Ongoing Cases: At the first procedural opportunity, parties in active lawsuits must submit this data to enable the judge to perform necessary notifications through telematic means, ensuring the guarantee of the right to defense.
Legal References:
- [1] Judgment dated August 12, 2022, Case No. AA20-C-2021-000213, issued by the SCC-TSJ. Available at: historico.tsj.gob.ve
- [2] Reasoning set forth by the Constitutional Chamber in Amparo Action No. 431, May 19, 2000 (Case: Proyectos Inverdoco, C.A.); reiterated in Constitutional Chamber Judgment No. 2314, December 18, 2007, and SCC Judgment No. 10, February 9, 2010.
- [3] Established Jurisprudence RH-N°61, dated June 22, 2001.